Method of making plastic beverage closure

ABSTRACT

A plastic beverage closure including a base wall, a peripheral skirt and a plurality of threads on the inner surface of the skirt for engagement with the threads of a container which may be made of glass or plastic. The plastic closure includes a compression molded seal extending about the periphery of the inner surface of the base wall and the juncture of the base wall to the peripheral skirt. The closure includes a central axially thickened portion; a channel surrounding the thickened portion and extending radially to an annular radially thickened portion on the skirt at the juncture with the base wall. A concave surface extends from the base of the channel and merges with the surface of the annular portion. A compression molded liner is provided on the thickened portion, channel and concave surface of the closure and defines a planar sealing surface of contact with the end surface of the finish of a container and an arcuate surface for engaging the arcuate surface of a container. In other forms, the closure can be used as a closure for non-beverage products.

This application is a continuation of application Ser. No. 08/088,673 filed Jul. 14, 1993, U.S. Pat. No. 5,462,187, which is a continuation-in-part of application Ser. No. 07/920,931 filed Jul. 28, 1992, U.S. Pat. No. 5,265,747.

This invention relates to plastic beverage closures and such closures when used on glass or plastic containers.

BACKGROUND AND SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

In the use of plastic beverage closures on glass or plastic containers, it is essential to provide a proper seal for the carbonated beverages in the glass or plastic containers. In addition, it is essential to be able to vent the pressure of the contents as the closure is being unthreaded and before the threads become disengaged in order to facilitate the opening of the contents. In order to vent the contents, the seal must first be released.

In order to provide a proper seal, it has been thought that it is necessary to have a seal on the top surface of the container as well as on the outer cylindrical surface of the finish or neck of the container. Thus, in compression mold liners a satisfactory seal has been provided as shown in, for example, U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,378,893, 4,407,422 and 4,418,828 incorporated herein by reference. In these patents, the closure is provided with an annular lip spaced from the base wall and defining an annular recess and a plastic sealing liner is compression molded such that it is held in position by integral liner-engaging projections on the base wall and the annular lip to form a liner that has an annular sealing bead that engages the outer side wall surface of the container. In another type of plastic beverage closure shown in U.S. Pat. Pat. Nos. 4,462,502 and 4,658,976, a circular flexible resilient liner is provided which is rotatable relative to the closure and has a diameter greater than the outside diameter of the container lip. An annular projection is provided at the juncture of the base wall and skirt of the closure and preferably has a configuration when viewed in cross-section which has a horizontal portion, a vertical and a convex portion connecting the horizontal and vertical portion one to the other providing for sealing along an outer cylindrical side surface of the edge of the finish of the container.

In each of the aforementioned constructions, the construction relies on the flexing of the base wall of the closure to enhance the side seal on the cylindrical surface of the container finish.

It has also been found that the nature of the seal provided is such that venting does not occur until a rotation of about 90°-120° of the closure occurs.

Among the objectives of the present invention are to provide a plastic beverage closure which has a seal which will effectively protect the contents of the container which may be under pressure; wherein the closure effectively vents any pressure of the container with a minimal rotation of the closure; which the closure is operable on both glass and plastic containers; wherein the liner material may be of a broad range of materials; which does not require an annular lip on the closure for retaining the sealing liner that might interfere with either the glass or plastic container finish; and which does not rely on a seal with the outer cylindrical surface of the finish of the container. It has also been found that the closure in some forms can be used for non-beverage products.

In accordance with the invention a plastic beverage closure comprising a base wall, a peripheral skirt and a plurality of threads on the inner surface of the skirt for engagement with the threads of a container which may be made of glass or plastic. the plastic closure includes a compression molded seal extending about the periphery of the inner surface of the base wall and the juncture of the base wall to the peripheral skirt. The closure includes a central axially thickened portion; a channel surrounding the thickened portion and extending radially to an annular radially thickened portion on the skirt at the juncture with the base wall. A concave surface extends from the base of the channel and merges with the surface of the annular portion. A compression molded liner is provided on the thickened portion; channel and concave surface of the closure and defines a planar sealing surface for contact with the end surface of the finish of the container and an arcuate surface for engaging the arcuate surface of a container. In other forms, the closure can be used as a closure for non-beverage products.

DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 is a fragmentary perspective view of a package comprising a plastic carbonated beverage closure and container embodying the invention.

FIG. 2 is a fragmentary vertical sectional view taken on an enlarged scale.

FIG. 3 is a fragmentary sectional view of a portion of FIG. 2 on a further enlarged scale.

FIG. 4 is a fragmentary sectional view of a portion of the container shown in FIG. 3.

FIG. 5 is a fragmentary sectional view of the closure shown in FIG. 4 without the container in position.

FIG. 6 is a fragmentary sectional view similar to FIG. 5 showing the closure before the compression molding liner in place.

FIG. 7 is a fragmentary sectional view taken along the line 7--7 in FIG. 6.

FIG. 8 is a bottom plan view of the closure shown in FIGS. 6 and 7.

FIG. 9 is a diagrammatic view of the plastic carbonated beverage closure.

FIG. 10 is a part sectional view of a closure on a plastic container.

FIG. 11 is a diagrammatic view of the closure shown in FIG. 10.

FIG. 12 is a part sectional view of a modified form of closure.

FIG. 13 is a part sectional view of a further modified form of closure.

FIG. 14 is a part sectional view of a modified form of closure embodying the invention.

FIG. 15 is a fragmentary view on a greatly enlarged scale of a portion of the closure shown in FIG. 14.

FIG. 16 is a fragmentary sectional view showing the closure on a container.

FIG. 17 is a part sectional view of another modified form of closure.

FIG. 18 is a fragmentary view on an enlarged scale of a portion of the closure shown in FIG. 17.

FIG. 19 is a fragmentary sectional view showing the closure on a container.

DESCRIPTION

Referring to FIGS. 1-8, the carbonated beverage package embodying the invention comprises a plastic closure 20 adapted to be threaded on a container C herein shown as being a glass container. The closure 20 is made of thermoplastic material such as polypropylene or polyethylene for glass and plastic containers including containers that are made of PET (polyethylene terephthalate).

The closure 20 includes a base wall 21 and a peripheral skirt 22. The closure further includes a central thickened portion 23 on its inner surface and an annular channel 24 surrounding the portion 23. The channel 24 is adapted to overlie the upper end of the finish of the container. The skirt 22 of the closure 20 has a radially thickened portion 25 on its inner surface defining a cylindrical surface 26. The base surface of the channel 24 tapers axially inwardly and radially inwardly to an annular tapered surface 27 that extends to the planar surface 28 on the central portion 23 (FIG. 6). The closure 20 includes an annular arcuate surface 29 that has a radius R₁ and extends substantially 90° from the outer edge of the channel 24 to the cylindrical surface 26.

As shown in FIGS. 2-5, a liner 30 of resilient material is compression molded in situ on the base wall 21 such that the sealing liner has a central portion 31 of uniform thickness on the inner surface of the central portion 23, a portion 32 along channel 24 and a portion 33 that is thicker at the juncture with the arcuate surface 29 of the closure. The liner 30 extends to the cylindrical surface 26, but has its free edge spaced from the lower edge of portion 25. The cylindrical surface 26 of the closure has a diameter greater than the outer diameters of the upper end of the finish F of the container C.

The liner 30 further includes an annular exterior planar surface 34 on the portion 32 that merges with an arcuate surface 35 of constant radius that extends to the free end 36 of the liner. The center of radius of the curved surface 32 of the closure and the curved surface 35 of the liner are preferably displaced axially and radially as indicated by the radial lines R₁, R₂ in FIG. 5. Thus, the thickest portion 33 of the liner 30 is at the juncture of the base wall 21 on the skirt 22 and preferably nearer the base wall 21 than the skirt 22. As a result, as shown in FIG. 4, the primary sealing occurs along the planar surface 34 and the curved portion 35 of the free end 36.

The radius R₂ of arcuate surface 35 of the liner 30 has its center nearer the axis of the closure 20 than the center of the radius R₁ of the arcuate surface 26 of the closure 20. The center of the radius R₂ is axially displaced vertically away from the base wall 21 a greater distance than the center of the radius R₁. The radius R₂ terminates at the free edge 36 and thus the curved surface 35 extends for less than 90° with respect to a horizontal plane while the curved surface 29 on the closure extends about 90° . Radius R₁ is preferably equal to radius R₂.

The closure 20 further includes interrupted threads 37 on the inner surface of skirt 22 defining venting axial grooves 38 for venting the pressure as the closure 20 is unthreaded from the threads 39 on the container 21, in a manner well known in the art. Interrupted threads are also preferably provided on the finish of the associated container if it is made of plastic.

The plastic beverage closure is also preferably provided with a tamper indicating band B (FIG. 3) which may be of any well known type but is preferably that shown and claimed in U.S. Pat. No. 5,090,788 incorporated by reference. The tamper indicating band is attached to the skirt by a plurality of weakened portions defining a line of severing. An annular flange extends axially upwardly and inwardly from the tamper indicating band toward the base wall of the closure and comprises a first continuous annular flange portion connected to the band by a hinge portion and a second portion which has free ends of the segment portions engaging beneath the bead on the container when the closure is threaded onto the container. In one form the second portion comprises a plurality of segment portions extending upwardly and inwardly from the first continuous portion. In another form, the second portion comprises a second continuous flange portion. The flange is bent intermediate its ends so that the second portion extends inwardly at a greater angle than the first continuous flange portion.

Other types of tampering indicating bands may also be used, as is well known in the art.

The liner material may comprise any known material that can be extruded and cut off to provide changes for compression molding an apparatus such as shown, for example, in U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,955,605, 4,080,136 and 4,277,431. The liner material must also match other closure requirements including satisfactory removal torques, carbonation retention, carbonation retention under top load and satisfactory functioning on a container when cycled through environmental changes of temperature and humidity. A satisfactory material is a blend of an ethylene vinyl acetate composition and a thermoplastic elastomeric composition, such as that of U.S. Pat. No. 4,984,703 incorporated herein by reference. Such a composition will function satisfactorily for glass containers as well as plastic containers. Other types of materials that function satisfactorily are ethylene vinyl acetate compositions and thermoplastic compositions.

In use, the plastic beverage closure 20 is applied to a container C after it has been filled and the closure is threaded onto the finish F at a predetermined torque. When a user desires to access the beverage, the user unthreads the closure causing the tamper indicating band to be severed. As the closure is being unthreaded, the seal is first released and the contents vented before the threads are disengaged.

It has been found through testing that a plastic beverage closure embodying the invention provides a seal on the top surface and corner outer radius of the container without the necessity of a seal along the cylindrical side surface of the finish of the container, has heretofore been thought to be necessary for a satisfactory beverage closure both in metal and plastic closures. In addition, the plastic beverage closure embodying the invention has been found to provide for venting of the pressure in the container during the time when there is maximum contact between the threads of the closure and the threads of the container, within the first portion of rotation of the closure removal. It has been found that the venting occurs within the first about 45° of rotation.

As shown in FIG. 9, which is a diagrammatic view, the closure embodying the invention is able to accommodate the tolerances in glass manufacture of glass containers, provide a satisfactory seal and meet the objective of satisfactory early venting. The lines show the nominal dimension G₁ maximum dimension G₂ and minimum dimension G₃.

As shown in FIGS. 10 and 11, the closure functions satisfactorily on plastic containers P. In this application, as is well known, plastic beverage containers are made by injection blow molding or reheat blow molding wherein a parison is first injection molded to form the finish and a hollow blowable body. In injection molding the top of the finish F' is formed by a one-piece locking ring mold that has a continuous annular cavity to form a seamless upper end 50. The remainder of the finish F' is formed by split molds that are closed and locked by the locking ring. This forms a small annular seam 51, shown enlarged in FIG. 10. The finish 50 includes a flat top surface 52 and an arcuate surface 53 merging with the flat surface 52 and a cylindrical surface 54. It may be noted that the closure does not have a liner that extends or contacts the seam 51.

As shown in FIG. 11, which is a diagrammatic view, the closure embodying the invention is able to accommodate the tolerances in plastic containers, provide a satisfactory seal and meet the objective of satisfactory early venting. The lines show the nominal dimension P₁, maximum dimension P₂ and minimum dimension P₃.

In a typical example of a 28 mm closure, the closure was made of polypropylene and the liner comprised ethylene vinyl acetate. The closure had the following dimensional relationships: Diameter of surface 26=0.996"; thickness of liner at intersection of surface 34 and 35 and intersection of surface 24 and 29=0.022"; radius R₁ =0.040"; radius R₂ =0.040"; diameter of lower edge of surface 35 at free edge 36=0.969"; axial height of surface 26 from the lower edge to the intersection of surfaces 24 and 29=0.075".

Such a plastic beverage closure functions satisfactorily on a glass container finish having the following dimensions: Diameter of outer cylindrical surfaces =0.978"; width of top surface =0.069"; radius of outer arcuate corner between the top surface and cylindrical surfaces =0.031".

Such a plastic beverage closure functions satisfactorily on a PET container finish having the following dimensions: Diameter of outer cylindrical surfaces =0.982"; width of top surface =0.060"; radius of outer arcuate corner between the top surface and cylindrical surfaces =0.025"; axial distance between top surface and annular seam 51 =0.045".

Tests of the plastic beverage closure having the dimensions set forth on the above-identified glass container finish and PET container finish indicate that there was a 100% effectiveness in what is known as a constant force top load test applied to a carbonated beverage; a secure seal test; a carbon dioxide retention test at 70° F.; and a carbon dioxide retention test at 108° F.

The constant force top load test consists of conditioning a carbonated package for three days at 100° F., placing the package in a press with a force gage on top of the closure and applying 100 psi to determine possible leakage.

The secure seal test is intended to determine whether proper closure/container contact is achieved. This test consists of applying pressure through an opening in the closure at 5 psi per second and holding the pressure at each level of 100 psi for one minute and 150 psi for one minute and observing at 175 psi. The standard is no leakage at the 100 psi or 150 psi level. In the case of plastic containers, the finish is pressurized internally in a fixture to adversely affect the side walls of a plastic container. The carbon dioxide retention test at 70° consists of storing carbonated packages at 70° for 12 weeks and checking the carbonation level in a Terris testing device at 1, 3, 6, 9 and 12 week intervals. The loss of carbonation is compared to a standard. The carbon dioxide retention test at 108° consists of storing carbonated packages at 108° for 3 days and checking the carbonation level in a Terris testing device. The loss of carbonation is compared to a standard.

This data can be summarized as follows:

    ______________________________________                                         CONSTANT FORCE TOP LOAD DATA                                                                         100% Pass @ 100° F.                               SECURE SEAL DATA      No Leakage 125 psi,                                                            Pass 175 psi                                             108° F. CO2 DATA                                                                              <2% C02 loss                                             CO2 RETENTION         No loss 1st week/                                                              <15% C02 loss total                                      ______________________________________                                    

In the form shown in FIG. 12 the continuous taper in the bottom of the channel is omitted and the channel is formed with circumferentially spaced radial ribs 60.

In the modified form of closure shown in FIG. 13, the base wall 21a of the closure has uniform thickness corresponding to the thickness of the central portion 23 in the other forms of closure. This substantially increases the rigidity of the base wall 21a. Thus, the planar surface 28a of the base wall 21a and the annular liner receiving surface 24a are coplanar. In all other respects, the closure including the sealing liner is the same as the previous forms of the invention.

In the modified form of a closure, shown in FIGS. 14-16, the closure 20b includes a base wall 21b and a frustoconical skirt 22b. The base wall has a uniform thickness. The skirt 22b has a radially thickened poriton 25b on its inner surface defining a cylindrical surface 26b. The closure 20b includes an annular arcuate surface 29b that has a radius R₁ and extends substantially 90° from the inner surface of the base wall 21b to the cylindrical surface 26b.

As shown in FIGS. 15 and 16, a liner 30b of resilient material is compression molded in situ on the base wall 23b such that the sealing liner has a central portion 32b of uniform thickness on the inner surface of the central portion 24b, and a portion 33b that is thicker at the juncture with the arcuate surface 29b of the closure. The liner 30b extends to the cylindrical surface 26b, but has its free edge spaced from the lower edge of portion 25b. The cylindrical surface 26b of the closure has a diameter greater than the outer diameters of the upper end of the finish F of the container C.

The liner 30b further includes an annular exterior planar surface 34b on the portion 32b that merges with an arcuate surface 35b of constant radius that extends to the free end 36b of the liner. The center of radius of the curved surface 32b of the closure and the curved surface 35b of the liner are preferably displaced axially and radially as indicated by the radial lines R₁, R₂ in FIG. 15. Thus, the thickest portion 33b of the liner 30b is at the juncture of the base wall 21b on the skirt 22b and preferably nearer the base wall 21b than the skirt 22b. As a result, as shown in FIG. 16, the primary sealing occurs along the planar surface 34b and the curved portion 35b of the free end 36b.

The radius R₂ of arcuate surface 35b of the liner 30b has its center nearer the axis of the closure 20b than the center of the radius R₁ of the arcuate surface 26b of the closure 20b. The center of the radius R₂ is axially displaced vertically away from the base wall 21b a greater distance than the center of the radius R₁. The radius R₂ terminates at the free edge 36b and thus the curved surface 35b extends for less than 90° with respect to a horizontal plane while the curved surface 29b on the closure extends about 90° . Radius R₁ is preferably equal to radius R₂.

In this form no tamper indicating band is provided. The container 21b does not require interrupted threads in a beverage closure.

In the form of closure shown in FIGS. 17-19, the clousre 20c is of the vacuum type and comprises the closure 20c includes a base wall 21c and a peripheral skirt 22c. The closure further includes a central thickened portion 23c on its inner surface. The skirt 22c of the closure 20c has a radially thickened portion 25c on its inner surface defining a cylindrical surface 26c. The closure 20c includes an annular arcuate surface 29c that has a radius R₁ and extends substantially 90° from the base surface 24 to the cylindrical surface 26c.

As shown in FIGS. 17-19, a liner 30c of resilient material is compression molded in situ on the base wall 21c such that the sealing liner has a central portion 31c of uniform thickness on the inner surface of the central portion 23c, and a portion 33c that is thicker at the juncture with the arcuate surface 29c of the closure. The liner 30c extends to the cylindrical surface 26c, but has its free edge spaced from the lower edge of portion 25c. The cylindrical surface 26c of the closure has a diameter greater than the outer diameters of the upper end of the finish F of the container C.

The liner 30c further includes an annular exterior planar surface 34c on the portion 32c that merges with an arcuate surface 35c of constant radius that extends to the free end 36c of the liner. The center of radius of the curved surface 32c of the closure and the curved surface 35c of the liner are preferably displaced axially and radially as indicated by the radial lines R₁, R₂ in FIG. 18. Thus, the thickest portion 33c of the liner 30c is at the juncture of the base wall 21c and the skirt 22c and preferably nearer the base wall 21c than the skirt 22c. As a result, as shown in FIG. 19, the primary sealing occurs along the planar surface 34c and the curved portion 35c of the free end 36c.

The radius R₂ of arcuate surface 35c of the liner 30c has its center nearer the axis of the closure 20c than the center of the radius R₁ of the arcuate surface 26c of the closure 20c. The center of the radius R₂ is axially displaced vertically away from the base wall 21c a greater distance than the center of the radius R₁. The radius R₂ terminates at the free edge 36c and thus the curved surface 35c extends for less than 90° with respect to a horizontal plane while the curved surface 29c on the closure extends about 90° . Radius R₁ is preferably equal to radius R₂.

The thickness of the top wall is such that the top wall will flex inwardly under vacuum as when the closure is filled with hot liquid which upon cooling forms a vacuum.

It can thus be seen that there has been provided a plastic beverage closure which has a seal which will effectively protect the contents of the container which are under pressure; wherein the closure effectively vents the contents of the container with a minimal rotation of the closure; which the closure is operable on both glass and plastic containers; wherein the liner material may be of a broad range of materials; which does not require an annular lip on the closure for retaining the sealing liner that might interfere with either the glass or plastic container finish; and which does not rely on a seal with the outer cylindrical surface of the finish of the container. In other forms, the closure can be used as a closure for non-beverage products. 

We claim:
 1. The method of making a plastic closure for a container which has a finish with a top surface portion, a cylindrical outer surface portion and a curved portion at a juncture of the top surface portion and the outer surface portion, which method comprisesforming a base wall, forming a peripheral skirt having an inner surface, forming an interengaging means on the inner surface of said skirt for engaging the container, said interengaging means being such that relative rotational movement is required to disengage the closure from the container, forming said base wall of said closure such that it has an inner surface with a central portion and an annular liner receiving portion surrounding said central portion, forming said skirt of said closure with a radially thickened portion adjacent the juncture of the base wall and the skirt and extending radially inwardly from the inner surface of said skirt and defining a cylindrical surface extending toward the base wall, forming said closure such that it has an annular concave surface at the juncture of the base wall and said skirt and merging with said annular liner receiving portion and said cylindrical surface at the juncture of the top surface portion and the outer surface portion of the finish, compression molding a liner such that said compression molded liner engages and conforms to the inner surface of said central portion, said annular liner receiving portion, said annular concave surface and said cylindrical surface, said liner overlies said central portion of said base wall of said closure, said annular liner receiving portion surrounding said central portion of said base wall of said closure, said annular concave surface of said closure and a portion of said cylindrical surface of said closure, said compression molding of said liner being such that said liner has an exterior planar surface in the portion adapted to overlie and engage the top surface of a finish of a container, a concave arcuate surface and a free edge contacting and terminating on the cylindrical surface on said closure, and such that said concave arcuate surface on said liner has a configuration and cooperates with said annular concave surface on said closure such that said liner has its greatest radial thickness from a point along a central axis that is disposed horizontally below the base wall of the closure in the portion of the liner between the annular liner receiving portion and the free edge of said liner, and such that said concave arcuate surface on the liner is adapted to engage the curved portion of said finish of the container at the juncture of the top surface portion and the outer surface portion of the finish and the curved portion on the exterior of said finish and terminates in advance of any cylindrical outer surface portion on the container.
 2. The method set forth in claim 1 wherein the forming of the closure is such that said annular liner receiving portion comprises a channel and said central portion comprises an axially thickened portion, said closure having an annular portion which tapers radially and axially inwardly from said channel to said thickened portion.
 3. The set forth in claim 2 wherein said compression molding of said liner is such that said liner includes a portion merging gradually between said portion overlying said central portion of said closure and said channel.
 4. The method set forth in claim 3 wherein the forming of the closure is such that said annular concave surface on said closure has a radius R₁ and said compression molding of said liner is such that said concave arcuate surface on said liner has a radius R₂, wherein an angular extent of R₁ is greater than R₂.
 5. The method set forth in claim 4 wherein the forming of the closure is such that the angular extent of said radius R₁ is about 90° and said compression molding of said liner is such that and angular extent of R₂ is less than 90° such that the gradually merging portion of the concave arcuate surface of the liner is not axially tangent to any cylinder passing through the free edge.
 6. The method set forth in claim 5 wherein the forming of the closure is such that the radii R₁ ═R₂, a center of said radius R₁ being axially and radially displaced such that the radially thickened portion of said liner is nearer said channel than said cylindrical surface of said closure.
 7. The method set forth in claim 1 wherein the forming of the closure is such that said central portion of the base wall of the closure and said compression molding of said liner is such that the annular liner receiving portion on the base wall of the closure are coplanar.
 8. The method set forth in claim 7 wherein the forming of the closure is such that said annular concave surface on said closure has said radius R₁ and said compression molding of said liner is such that said annular concave surface on said liner has said radius R₂, wherein the angular extent of R₁ is greater than R₂.
 9. The method set forth in claim 8 wherein the forming of the closure is such that the angular extent of radius R₁ is about 90° and said compression molding of said liner is such that the angular extent of R₂ is less than 90° such that the gradually merging portion of the concave arcuate surface of the liner is not axially tangent to any cylinder passing through the free edge.
 10. The method set forth in claim 9 wherein the radii R₁ ═R₂, the center of said radius R₁ being axially and radially displaced such that the radially thickened portion of said liner is nearer said channel than said cylindrical surface of said closure.
 11. The method set forth in any one of claims 1-10 including providing a container which comprises a glass container having a finish top surface, an outer cylindrical surface and an arcuate surface joining said top surface and cylindrical surface, said liner providing a seal only with said top surface and arcuate surface and applying said closure to said container.
 12. The method set forth in any one of claims 1-10 including providing a container which comprises a plastic container, said container having a finish with a top surface, a continuous seamless outer surface terminating in an annular seam and an annular convex surface joining the top surface and outer side surface, said liner providing a seal with said top surface and continuous seamless outer surface only and applying said closure to said container.
 13. The method set forth in any one of claims 1-10 including providing a tamper indicating on said closure.
 14. The method set forth in claim 13 including providing a container which comprises a glass container having a finish top surface, an outer cylindrical surface and an arcuate surface joining said top surface and cylindrical surface, said liner providing a seal only with said top surface and arcuate surface and applying said closure to said container.
 15. The method set forth in claim 13 including providing a container which comprises a plastic container, said container having a finish with a top surface, a continuous seamless outer surface terminating in an annular seam and an annular convex surface joining the top surface and outer side surface, said liner providing a seal with said top surface and continuous seamless outer surface only and applying said closure to said container. 